Fic: Spill My Heart
Author: Sarah (Spoiledsquish)
Reviewer: Stacie
Summary: Post-Chosen; Buffy heads to L.A. to say her goodbyes and to save Fred the only way she can.
· Grammar: A couple of places where a comma would have been better; A word was left out ("I know that you can be when Angel won't have the will to live."; A few places where the spacebar didn't work.
· Spelling: I didn't see any mistakes. Yay! :-p
· Improbability: Technically, it's Canon, so *Suspension of Disbelief*
· Cliché: It's (becoming) a cliché but that little twist makes it different from the other things I've read.
· Plot Development: Well, we've moved along at a rather nice pace actually. Buffy set out to save Fred, did, and said her goodbye to Angel.
· Characterization: Very nice. The last chapter was touching and very Buffy/Angel-like.
· Use of Words/Description: There were a few places where I thought that maybe a little bit more
could've been written. (Liz's comments: Damn descriptions all to hell! Don't you hate them
sometimes? I do. I can't always seem to write what I'm thinking in my head. Dani Shafer [of
Sempiternal Beloved] gave me some advice: In the first draft of your fic, write minimal descriptions.
As you keep reading and rereading your fic, add more and develop the descriptions within each
paragraph.)
· Continuity: From the show and in the story.
· Dialogue: Believable. So rare in fics that are set around when a show is cancelled.
· Tediousness: There was a bit of repetition but I wasn't bored and I managed to read it all and still wish that more had been written. I don't even like Canon. :p (Liz's comments: Wow. I've never heard that from her before. *Impressed*.)
· Diction: Word choices were good. I didn't see any places where I thought, "This should have been
written more like blah blah correction-cakes."
Feedback (how I would like this if I was a normal reviewer): Ahh! The ninth chapter has a song! But, I'm willing to get over it because it fits. (Liz's
comments: God only knows how many writers out there use songs that do not fit *at
all* within the story.) I loved that the last chapter was so tear-jerking. Comments on Judging: Rather nicely done actually. This
could have been made sappy to the extreme but it was...reserved. I was
left feeling a little depressed, but I think that maybe that was the
intent. (Liz's comments: Getting the button ready…)
Advice:
A bit more description of surroundings would be nice. (Liz's comments: Those damned descriptions…)